Marc Wilson
As a member of the BYU Cougars, Wilson was a true athletic prodigy. He once said that football was the sport he was least good at. You wouldn’t know it based on the great college numbers he put up or the way that he helped revolutionize the concept of a pass-heavy offense. In that respect, Wilson became one of the first warning signs to professional scouts that dominant college stars don’t always make for great NFL players.
Wilson won a Super Bowl with the Raiders as a backup in the year he was drafted and proceeded to have an entirely unremarkable pro career afterward. He didn’t play in the NFL after 1990, finishing his career with 86 touchdowns and 102 interceptions. After football, Wilson became a top-notch real estate developer, putting football entirely behind him.