2008: Vince Young, Tennessee Titans
After being taken by the Tennessee Titans with the third overall pick in the 2007 NFL Draft, Vince Young led his team to the playoffs in his first year in the NFL, which was a major factor in him winning the NFL’s Offensive Rookie of the Year award. But Young struggled in his playoff debut, throwing for only 138 yards and no touchdowns (he did throw an interception). As we all know, Young’s career began to spiral downwards from there, as a result of his general immaturity and his clashes with head coach Jeff Fisher. Young never started another postseason game for the remainder of his career.