Reggie Bush – New Orleans Saints (2009)
It’s not the fact that Reggie Bush was a terrible player in general; he did finish his career recording two seasons with more than 1,000 yards rushing. But despite investing the #2 overall pick in the 2006 NFL Draft on Bush, and considering everyone assumed Bush was this generational, franchise-changing talent, the Saints never got a season with more than 600 yards rushing out of him.
Bush didn’t even lead the Saints in rushing during the 2009 season, when the team ended up defeating the Indianapolis Colts in the Super Bowl. But, Bush can still list “Super Bowl champion” next to his name (especially since all his college accolades have basically been removed from the record books).