Aaron Moorehead – Indianapolis Colts (2006)
People used to joke that Peyton Manning could insert his mailman as a wide receiver in one the Indianapolis Colts’ offenses that he led in the 2000’s, and turn said mailman into a 500-yard receiver. Such a hypothetical experiment wasn’t far off from the Aaron Moorhead experience.
In five NFL seasons, the former fourth-round pick in the 2003 NFL Draft played as a reserve receiver for the Colts, though he never finished with more than eight catches in any season — again, despite catching balls from Peyton Manning. Moorehead never had more than 101 yards receiving in any single season he played in Indianapolis, and during his five-year career, he found the end zone a grand total of one time.