2017: DeShone Kizer, Cleveland Browns
Imagine what life must feel like for a Cleveland Browns fan. In 2016, your team traded out of the spot that ended up yielding Carson Wentz, who is the favorite to win the MVP award in 2017. This past season, your team traded out of the #12 spot, in which the Houston Texans — the team they traded with — ended up taking Deshaun Watson, who was easily the most exciting rookie quarterback the league had seen in years, until his season-ending injury. And your consolation prize in all of this was quarterback Deshone Kizer, an overmatched rookie who’s thrown an NFL-high 11 interceptions in only seven games this season. Ouch!