6. Jimmy Garoppolo, QB, (Overrated)
There’s a good chance that we’re all simply biased towards Jimmy Garoppolo because he’s an absolutely unfairly good-looking guy; even guys would admit that. But as far as what he’s done on the field? Don’t let his 5-0 record toward the end of the 2017 season distract you from the fact that he never had more than two touchdown passes in any of those games, and threw an interception in four of those five games.
At the start of the 2018 season, Garoppolo threw three interceptions in San Francisco’s opener against Minnesota, and had a QB rating of less than 41 in his first two starts in 2018. Let’s not go declaring him as the second coming of Joe Montana just yet. With Jimmy G out for the season, NFL fans and the 49ers organization will have to wait and see if the young stud is worth the handsome 5-year $137.5 million deal he signed this past off-season.