2012. Andrew Luck (Pick: Andrew Luck)
All the hype around the top offensive prospects entering the 2012 NFL Draft turned out to be a huge bust, except for quarterback Andrew Luck. Hailed as a generational prospect, and perhaps the best quarterback coming into the draft since John Elway, Luck had a very promising start to his NFL career before injuries began to derail it.
However, he’s had a tremendous rebound year in 2018, and working with head coach Frank Reich seems like the perfect antidote to getting his career back on track. You can’t fault the Indianapolis Colts for making this pick, even over guys like Luke Kuechly and Chandler Jones.