Buffalo Bills: Nathan Peterman (2017-2018)
Perhaps the biggest punchline for poor quarterbacking jokes we’ve had over the past decade. Not even lasting two seasons with the Buffalo Bills, Peterman started four games (and appeared in four more), throwing a staggering 12 interceptions in those games, finishing with a 32.5 passer rating.
How bad is that? Consider that if Peterman had actually thrown an incomplete pass on every attempt, he would’ve actually had a better passer rating than that.