24. Art Schlichter
Schlichter’s off field legal issues qualify him for our list because they were directly related to his on field ability to be a teammate. As most people know Art Schlichter was an incredibly talented quarterback and a gambling addict.
It got so bad for Schlichter he eventually had to become an FBI witness to avoid his bookies black mailing him. While he claims to having never thrown games, the NFL kicked him out for gambling on other sports. Who wants to be teammates with a guy who you aren’t sure has the team’s best interests at the center of his on field actions?