Carson Palmer
Advertisement
It’s a little unfair to call Palmer overrated because he’s going to garner serious consideration from the Hall of Fame. He also deserves a lot of credit for being able to come back from serious injuries on multiple occasions.
However, despite throwing for nearly 300 touchdowns and having over 100 more touchdowns than interceptions, Palmer only played in four playoff games, and in one of them, he only threw one pass before getting hurt. Without leading his team to a few more playoff appearances, you have to admit that Palmer is a little overrated.
Advertisement
Superdude says
Aikman and Vick do not belong on this list. If anything they both are under rated!
JTT says
Why is Romo on this list when he had no offensive lines until 2014 and had some of the worst (historically for a couple of season) defenses?
Had Romo played for Belichick he would have won as many titles as Brady won under this tutelage.
Aikman, Favre, Stafford must be joke selections.
Ivan Castro says
Not a bad list, but Aikman, Romo and Favre deserve better than being in this list.
Devin says
Kirk Cousins is Trash. The vikings should fire everyone associated with his signing!!
Raj says
YES, Terry Bradshaw should be on the list as well …….otherwise VERY ACCURATE….!!
Rafael Muniz says
Where the hell is Andrew Luck in this list. He was suppose to be bigger than the second coming yet he did nothing in the NFL.
Bobby says
Stafford is a flop Detroit’s biggest most expensive flop. Unfair that’s a joke most of his yards were when the other team dropped back and gave up yards & scores after the game was lost. He’s a horrible decision maker on the field. His leadership skills consist of emotionless excuses on why the team failed. He makes Kyle Orton look like a hall of famer and I didn’t like him either.
Dalton says
A QB must have great players around him in order to be a winner throughout his career. Terry Bradshaw should be on this list since he threw 212 Touchdowns in his career but also threw 210 interceptions. He had many great players on the Steeler teams or he would have been considered an average NFL QB at best. Aikman and Farve don’t belong on this list.
larry Nall says
Concussions piled up from helmet to helmet and chin hits. He did not receive the same officiating that Brady and Favre received and declined quickly after Smih and Johnson left.
Randy says
Most of these guys are not overrated because nobody thinks there any good in the first place(flaco,hostetler,kosar but Stafford definitely is not overrated when he’s done playing his numbers will be as good as just about anyone also I would have liked to seen Jake Plummer get more of a chance
Ellen Eustace says
How is Brett Favre overrated? He won records and held onto one title till well after his retirement. He won a Super Bowl and led the Packers into the playoffs every year. He’s a legend. He deserves every accolade he’s ever gotten.
Rafael Muniz says
I totally agree with you
John Smith says
Bit unfair to Stafford. Does anyone seriously think that Rodgers or Brady could win with that club?!