11. Trent Dilfer (overrated)

People forget that Dilfer was an Elite 11 quarterback in high school and the 6th-overall pick back in 1994, but only ever developed into a glorified game manager. He does have a Super Bowl ring to show for his efforts, but let’s be honest, the Baltimore defense won that Super Bowl.

In the end, he only made one Pro Bowl and finished his career with a modest 55% completion percentage and more interceptions than touchdowns. Come on, that’s a below-average quarterback in any era.