12. Phil Simms (underrated)
Kids, Phil Sims isn’t just that guy whose job Tony Romo stole, he was an outstanding NFL quarterback. Simms ranks 23rd in NFL history for career passing yards with 33,462. Simms was named to two Pro Bowl, in 1985 and 1993.
But his greatest moment as a professional came in Super Bowl XXI when he completed 22 of 25 passes and three touchdowns. He set an NFL postseason record with a 150.9 passer rating for the game and most importantly won the game.