1. Eli Manning (overrated)
Yes, winning Super Bowls means a lot, but it’s not everything. The 20 weeks that come before a Super Bowl mean something too. Look, Eli is a talented quarterback who’s had quite a few good seasons and some incredibly special moments.
But winning two Super Bowls doesn’t mean he’s on the same level as John Elway, or Joe Montana, and especially not his older brother. The fact that people legitimately believe that because David Tyree made an unbelievable catch and the Giants defense played two great Super Bowls against the Patriots is why Eli will always be overrated.