2015: Andy Dalton, Cincinnati Bengals
It’s like Déjà vu all over again. For the third season in a row, Andy Dalton led the Cincinnati Bengals to double-digit wins in the regular season, and was named to the Pro Bowl team for the second time in his first four seasons in the NFL. But when the playoffs come around, he turns into a big orange pumpkin (with red hair). When the Bengals played the Indianapolis Colts in the AFC Wild Card game, Dalton went 18-35, throwing for only 155 yards, and taking three sacks. Once again, Cincinnati didn’t score a single point in the second half of the 26-10 loss. If you’re keeping score at home: in Dalton’s first three playoff games, he threw one touchdown, but had 10 turnovers (six interceptions and four fumbles lost).