Brady Quinn, Cleveland Browns, 2007
Before the 2007 NFL Draft, there were NFL draft analysts who felt like Brady Quinn should be a top-10 pick in the draft, comparing him to another Carson Palmer. But Quinn famously fell to the 22nd pick in the draft, as he waited in agony with his increasingly bored girlfriend at the time, before being taken by the Cleveland Browns. After three injury-marred seasons in Cleveland, the Browns traded him to the Denver Broncos in exchange for a low-round pick and fullback Peyton Hillis. Quinn bounced around five more NFL teams over the next five years.