2003: Jeff Blake, Arizona Cardinals
“Shake and Bake” Jeff Blake made a name for himself in the mid-1990’s, going from a sixth-round pick by the Cincinnati Bengals to a Pro Bowl quarterback for the team in 1995. But after leaving Cincinnati a few years later for “greener pastures,” Blake could never recapture that success. After pit stops in New Orleans and Baltimore, he had a brief stint in Arizona, which was absolutely disastrous. He lost 10 of the 13 games that he started for the team that year, and finished with a 69.6 passer rating. Blake completed just 56% of his passes and tossed a measly 13 touchdowns compared to 15 interceptions. Unsurprisingly, Blake bounced around two more teams after that, before his NFL career ended.