Indiana Pacers star Paul George fell in love with the homes on the Geist Reservoir, after former teammate George Hill recommended the area. His mansion sits on a peninsula, with views of the water on three sides. The back of his home leads to a dock, where many residents take their boats out to go fishing. Despite the gated neighborhood featuring premium security features, in 2014, George’s home was robbed, by thieves who stole nearly $16,000 worth of property. The robber was eventually caught and sentenced to 14 years in prison. Ouch!